StoryGraph vs Goodreads
The StoryGraphA view of your reading
Explore charts and choose books by mood.
GoodreadsA shelf of books
Keep shelves, browse reviews and follow friends.
Consider StoryGraph for mood filters, reading charts and progress-gated book discussion. Keep Goodreads if its reviews, shelves and people already meet your needs. Both advertise fractional ratings on iPhone. Try one representative book before deciding whether to move your reading history or use both services.
A ReadersGuild guide. About the publisher. Revised .
We make ReadersGuild, a different reading app. It is not a contender in this table. This comparison uses public documentation, not a hands-on competitor test. Read the sources and method.
Compare the reading workflow
| Task | ||
|---|---|---|
| Choosing books | Mood, pace and topic filters, plus recommendations. | Reader reviews, shelves and recommendations. |
| Looking back | Standard charts; Plus adds custom filters and comparisons. | Reading Challenge and Year in Books, as described in its listing. |
| Reading with others | Buddy reads with reactions hidden until others reach the relevant progress point; book clubs. | Follow friends, comment on reviews and join groups. |
| Ratings | Half and quarter stars in its official feature list. | Current iPhone listing advertises half and quarter stars. Web/Android parity was not tested. |
| Platforms and access | Web, iOS and Android. Free core features and optional Plus. | Web, iOS and Android. Free. |
| Existing records | Documents Goodreads import, including custom shelves mapped to tags. | Library CSV export provides a copy to keep before moving. |
Consider StoryGraph if
- You want to filter a next read by mood or pace.
- You want charts and private notes alongside your progress.
- You want to discuss a book without seeing later reactions too soon.
Consider Goodreads if
- You use the reviews and shelves to choose books.
- Your existing friends or groups are a reason to keep the account.
- You prefer your current workflow and have no missing task another app solves.
Make the choice with one book
Choose the activity you will repeat, not the app with more highlighted comparison rows. Searching reviews and inspecting a mood chart solve different jobs.
Keep both if you want Goodreads for discovery and StoryGraph for your personal record. That means deciding which service you update first, so two accounts do not become two unfinished logs.
Before moving your library
Keep the original Goodreads CSV. StoryGraph documents importing reading statuses and mapping custom shelves to tags. Check a finished book, an unfinished book, a rating and a date after processing. Do not delete the source account or assume a library file contains timed sessions.
Keep a Goodreads library backupHow we compared the apps
Published by ReadersGuild, a reading app. Sources reviewed October 31, 2026: public product documentation and available store listings. This is a source-based comparison, not a hands-on competitor test. Recommendations reflect the task each product documents. Store offers and platform features can vary by region and version.
Questions before choosing
Want company for your next reading session?
In ReadersGuild, friends can bring their own books into a shared room and read at the same time. Check the iPhone workflow if company is the part you want to add.
ReadersGuild for iPhone
Read together, with your own books.
Open a reading room and share its code with a friend. Read quietly together, without an assigned title or a discussion to prepare.
See reading together on iPhoneFree to start. Optional paid upgrades. Android is on the email waitlist.